Great article!
Yesterday the New York Times visited 360i’s New York office. The folks at nytimes.com met with agency creative directors to discuss fresh approaches to display advertising. They shared with us some new integration opportunities for advertising and editorial, including the newest Apple homepage roadblock ad.
By now everyone who has visited the Wall Street Journal, CNN, Wired or NYT online (or read the trades) in the last few months has seen one or more of these placements. The most recent Apple ads featured the Mac and PC characters discussing how PC is as easy to use as 1 through 23 steps, mostly involving restarts. Another ad showed hundreds of iPhone app icons flying over the publisher masthead, across the page and into a waiting iPhone. The payoff: “Thanks a billion. One billion downloads. Only on the App Store.”
What you may not know is that these unique roadblock ads that dogleg homepage content on news sites are exclusive ad units, at least on the New York Times’ site. The New York Times offered exclusive placement as part of the media commitment.
The bad news: Given the exclusivity in the near-term, other marketers won’t be able to use this innovative ad shape to grab attention.
The good news: The new ad unit seems popular with readers, according to the Times. Although this may be a testament to the strength of the Apple campaign, more importantly, it may signal a new opportunity for collaboration between agencies and publisher editorial departments to develop new ways to engage consumers.
For instance, Cisco is partnering with the NYT to offer TimesPeople, a new mini social network that allows Times readers to share articles with each other. The integrated sponsorship allows Cisco to personify its “human network” brand strategy. Check it out at the very top of the NYT homepage.
Here are some of my predictions for emerging trends in online display advertising out of all of this:
1. On some sites, marketers will increasingly be able to integrate editorial. NYT is now offering “nano-sites,” which are essentially adver-content microsites that live on nytimes.com and can include editorial. These nano-sites carry the benefit of one less click for consumers to interact with rich advertiser content.
2. To help prove the value of display, more publishers will disrupt editorial for innovative ad placements. Over-the-page animations, expandables and roadblocks may soon be the norm on news and other demo-desirable publisher homepages.
3. Creative ideas will rule the day. Agencies, marketers and publishers will need to collaborate to find big ideas to justify interrupting Web pages and the consumer experience. As the oft-quoted Peter Parker so aptly put it, “with great power comes great responsibility.”
Great article!
Creative ideas need to factor in the audience of the property as well. Unfortunately the economy has forced many pubs to allow advertisers to dominate their user experience (aptly called roadblock ads). While Apple + NYT may be able to get away with this, a majority of properties and brands will not. Just ask yourself if the NYT did this type of Ad with Microsoft would everyone be all excited, calling this the start of a new agency publisher collaboration? Not a chance! If the Apple ad played on an IT dominated site to tech folks, say slashdot, would they all be talking about how great the ads were? no way!
Don’t get me wrong, I think this is indeed a creative approach and if you have the right audience and the right advertiser it can do well. I happen to be a Mac user and liked the ads personally. But it’s just not something that will work across all properties with all ads so in the end it’s another custom ad unit. Pubs will need to balance if such an ad that dominates their user experience will be accepted by their audience or cause them to leave. @robblewis
Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.